Questioning to Develop Mathematicians

Our final question in The Math Pod (#themathpod) twitter chat this past week (see the archive here), was built on Cathy Fosnot's challenge for us in the first podcast:
What is the difference between questions meant to guide students to a specific answer vs. questioning to support development as a mathematician?


 So in the chat we asked:
What kind of questions can we ask to support development as a mathematician?
What would you actually say to your students?

 Here are some of the answers from the participants in the chat:
What kind of questions can we ask to support development as a mathematician?
What would you say to your students?

Tell me about what you're doing.
What do you wonder?
Tell me more?
How did you know that?
What if i change this?
Really??? (especially when they're right!)
Can you explain what she just said?
What made you think of that?
How did you figure that out?
What does this remind you of?
Have you seen what (another kid) is doing?
Can you draw a picture of the problem?

I know that when I'm interacting with a couple dozen different students in a busy classroom, I like to have a couple of go-to questions or reactions in my back pocket, so I find lists like these very helpful. It's tough to get away from just confirming or correcting what the students are guessing - it will take practice to be able to implement these questions instead!

 In addition to our responses to Cathy's challenge, there was also lots to consider about the questioning process, and asking questions in general:
Capacity Building Series #21: Asking Effective Questions

It will be interesting to see how Cathy addresses the topic in tonight's live podcast. 

How do you question students to get at their thinking, or encourage students to justify their reasoning, or have students make connections with what they've learned?


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

One Word 2018

Image
It's that time of year again - a time for reflection and contemplation on the past year, and a time for setting new goals for a new year. Calm, and reflective. The past few Decembers, I've participated in the #onewordONT community, choosing a single word that summarizes my outlook and goals for the next year as I move forward in my professional practice. For 2015 , my word was JUMP - jumping into new adventures and taking risks to try new things. For 2016 , my word was REFLECTION - working more reflection into my practice as a teacher, but also helping my students reflect on their learning. For 2017 , my word was PATIENCE - practicing patience with both myself in learning a new role, and with the process of implementing change. It won't happen overnight. PATIENCE was a good focus for me this past year as I work my way toward deeper understanding. Coming out of the classroom, I've been involved in many learning opportunities in my new-ish role as a math co
Read more

Never as Easy as it Looks

Last week, I was fortunate enough to attend three days of workshops with Cathy Fosnot ( @ctfosnot ) in North Bay. This was a great opportunity to see so many constructs in person that I had previously only learned about through her books, or the podcasts with #notabookstudy and #themathpod. It was amazing to see "math congress," "mini-lessons," and "gallery walks" come to life! Also last week, I wrote about how math teachers can change how they ask questions in order to probe for concept development, rather than probing for just the answer. Inspired by what I had seen in North Bay, I wanted to try out this different style of questioning first hand. While working with different learners this week, I tried going past just getting the answer, and encouraged them to show me how they got their answer, or to draw a picture, or to explain their thinking in words, or tell me how they know their answer could be right. The results were disastrous. Learners be
Read more

The Art of Questioning on Math Assessments

Image
Last year, I had a great conversation with a colleague around math assessment. We were talking primarily about how to best triangulate products, observations, and conversations to form an overall balanced assessment of student learning, but a side conversation has really stuck with me. She told me that on her math tests, for any given learning goal, she gives the students four levels of questions to choose from. The students can then decide how to best demonstrate their understanding of that expectation. I love the idea of student voice and student choice in how learning is demonstrated. But it's taken me about a year to really wrap my head around this idea, and to start working with teachers in my board to try it out. Traditionally... Traditionally, on a test, I might ask students three or four questions all on the same expectation. It might look something like this: Like most teachers, I started with an easy problem, and each subsequent problem gets a little more invo
Read more